Plans by the Obama
administration to do away with tax credits for US oil and gas companies have
been made hastily and could come back to haunt both the administration and US
consumers, in the form of increased oil imports and higher energy costs, a
panel of oil and gas experts said on Tuesday.
Obama's budget proposal
published last month will add $31.5 billion to the tax burden borne by domestic
oil and gas producers over a 10-year period. It is part of a broad plan to
increase energy independence that includes a cap-and-trade system for
greenhouse gas emissions.
Much of Obama's energy
policy was developed during his presidential campaign when oil prices soared above
$100 a barrel, allowing wind and solar power to compete on price with oil, natural
gas and coal as a way of increasing the security of US energy supplies.
But analysts said the
new administration has failed to adjust its policies to an economic recession
and the rapid collapse of oil prices. Raising domestic costs for oil and
natural gas development will only replace domestic crude with imported supplies
and will stall domestic gas exploration, they argued.
"The deteriorating
economic climate caused a reversal so that everything has been recast as a
"green" jobs program, said Frank Verrastro,
Energy Director with the Center for Strategic and International Studies who
worked with the Obama campaign on its energy platform."When
you try to find folks with within the administration, there is a
"green" group and a realist group. There is concern on the oil and
gas side that there is no one to talk to."
Treasury Secretary
Timothy Geithner gave some insight into the Obama's
thinking on energy policy earlier this month, telling senators that "for
people whose behavior in energy use doesn't change, their costs will go up. You
can't achieve these objectives if you don't change the incentives."
The White House budget proposal assumes that at least
$79 billion per year in revenues will be generated from a cap-and-trade system
for greenhouse gas emissions that will become operational in 2012. Obama's ambitious
plans to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by about 14% below 2005 levels by 2020
go a long way to explaining the proposal to end tax credits and incentives that
were granted to oil and gas producers in the past.
"It is a punitive
tax penalizing only the domestic oil and gas industry," James Gallogly, ConocoPhillips exploration and production chief told
an energy seminar in Washington.
"Overtaxing domestic industry reduces it competiveness and makes foreign
sources more attractive, increasing the likelihood of greater imports."
Meanwhile the new
administration has suffered a loss of momentum because it is still struggling
to place people in positions of authority at the Energy and Interior departments
and the Environmental Protection Agency.
"Our efforts to
draft an energy bill are being hampered because we simply don't have the
political folks in the departments to advise us," said Lisa Murkowski,
(R-Alaska) ranking member on the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee.
"The departments are still unable to give witnesses to our hearings."
Appointments for
undersecretaries and deputy secretaries in many executive branch positions have
been slowed by stricter White House rules against lobbyists entering public
office.
Bill Murray, Washington